
Consumer Contradictions
Why Food & Drink Shoppers Increasingly Want It All
4 min read
10th October 2026
Consumers have always wanted food to taste good. But today's purchasing decision is increasingly more complicated.
Health. Price. Convenience. Quality. Sustainability. Familiarity. Indulgence.
Rather than one consideration replacing another, consumers increasingly expect food and beverage products to deliver against several priorities at the same time.
And that is creating an interesting challenge for food and beverage manufacturers: how do you give consumers more of what they want, without compromising the things they already value?

1. HEALTH × INDULGENCE
“I want to eat better — but I still want to enjoy it.”
The latest FSA Food and You 2 research found that 75% of respondents had made at least one change to their eating habits for health reasons in the previous 12 months. Among those making changes, 49% had eaten less processed food, 48% had reduced sugar or high-sugar foods and drinks, and 46% had eaten more fruit and vegetables.
But behaviour becomes more nuanced when food is consumed for enjoyment. Separate FSA research found that while 67% of consumers said they try to choose healthier versions when shopping for food, only 25% said they try to choose a healthier option when eating out. (Food Standards Agency)
Health matters — but enjoyment hasn't disappeared.
Consumers aren't necessarily looking for a world without cakes, desserts, snacks or indulgent foods. The opportunity is increasingly about finding ways to make healthier choices without making them feel like a compromise.

2. CONVENIENCE × QUALITY
“Make my life easier — but don't lower my expectations.”
AHDB, using Kantar Usage data, reports that 71% of all meal occasions were eaten at home in the 52 weeks ending December 2024. At the same time, average preparation time for an evening meal had fallen to just 31 minutes, an all-time low in the dataset, alongside growth in meals that are quicker and easier to prepare. (AHDB)
Consumers want less preparation — not necessarily less quality.
For manufacturers, convenience therefore isn't simply about speed. Products still have to deliver on flavour, appearance, texture and overall experience.
"When preparing meals for the family, 67% of consumers identify taste and 64% quality as important considerations, alongside value, ease of cooking, convenience and health." (AHDB)
3. SUSTAINABILITY × AFFORDABILITY
“I want to make responsible choices — but I still have a budget.”
Sustainability remains part of the consumer conversation, but it exists alongside an equally powerful concern: affordability.
PwC's 2025 global consumer research found that 44% of consumers are willing to pay more for food to support environmental sustainability. Yet 56% would choose a more cost-effective product produced outside their country rather than pay a premium for locally produced food.
The tension is particularly visible in the UK. In March 2026, the FSA found that 91% of respondents expressed concern about food prices, while 77% were concerned about food waste in the food chain. (FSA)
Rising inflation and cost-pressures will undoubtedly impact consumers purchasing behaviour when it comes to sustainable choices.

4. HEALTH × AFFORDABILITY × CONVENIENCE
“I want to eat well — but it needs to fit my budget and my life.”
Recent YouGov/AHDB research found 85% of consumers said diet was important to their health. Yet among adults who considered diet and/or fitness important, 71% said healthy food and drinks are too expensive, impacting purchase. AHDB also reports that an average evening meal containing a healthy element cost 13% more than one without. (AHDB)
Consumers want healthier products that are accessible, convenient and affordable enough to become everyday choices!
5. SIMPLICITY × PERFORMANCE
“I want to understand what's in my food — but I still expect it to deliver.”
The latest FSA survey found that among people who had changed their diets for health reasons, 49% reported eating less processed food and 48% had reduced foods and drinks high in sugar. (Food Standards Agency)
The interesting challenge for manufacturers is that consumers may want products they perceive as simpler while continuing to expect:
great taste • appealing texture • stability • shelf life • convenience • consistent quality
The challenge isn't meeting one expectation. It's meeting several at once.
"51% of consumers cited food manufacturers and processors in the top three for being primarily responsible for encouraging healthy and nutritious eating" . (pwc)

MORE COMPLEX CONSUMER EXPECTATIONS CREATE MORE COMPLEX PRODUCT BRIEFS
-
A reduced-sugar product still needs to taste indulgent
-
A convenient meal still needs to deliver an enjoyable texture and eating experience
-
A nutritionally enhanced beverage still needs to remain appealing and stable
-
A reformulated product still needs to perform throughout manufacturing, distribution and shelf life
-
And a more sustainable choice still needs to be commercially viable
FROM CONSUMER EXPECTATION TO FORMULATION REALITY...
At Thew Arnott, we work across food and beverage categories where these expectations increasingly overlap. Understanding the consumer trend is only the beginning. The challenge is translating it into products that work — technically, commercially and for the consumer.
The future of food may not be about choosing between health, convenience, value, sustainability and enjoyment. It may be about finding better ways to deliver them together.